The New York Police Department's (NYPD) claim that industrial-grade chains were used by pro-Palestine protesters to barricade buildings is being met with doubt and full-throttle mockery online.
The pushback began following an interview with Deputy Commissioner Tarik Sheppard, who was seen holding up a set of chains and a bike lock that the police encountered while clearing a building taken over by protesters.
"This is not what students bring to school, okay? This is what professionals bring to campuses and universities," Sheppard said. "These are heavy, industrial chains that were locked with bike locks. And this is what we encountered on every door inside of Hamilton Hall."
Sheppard said the team had to cut through those chains and get through doors that had been "barricaded with refrigerators, vending machines, chairs, you name it."
"But our guys would not be stopped, they did a fantastic job of entering into that location and taking people into custody without incident last night," he added. "They took about 40 or 50 people into custody inside the lobby of Hamilton Hall last night."
Deputy Commissioner Tarik Sheppard shows the chains used to secure Hamilton Hall at Columbia University.
— Morning Joe (@Morning_Joe) May 1, 2024
"This is not what students bring to school. This is what professionals bring to campuses and universities." pic.twitter.com/fwFUPZlIj7
But Shepard's comments drew immediate pushback, with some social media users noting that the chain appears to be the same that Columbia University's Public Safety department itself sells to students as part of their "Crime Prevention Discount Bike, Locker and Laptop Lock Program."
This bike lock is/was available for sale on campus via Columbia's Public Safety department under their "Crime Prevention Discount Bike, Locker and Laptop Lock Program".
— Aric Toler (@AricToler) May 1, 2024
See their flier with a discount here: https://t.co/cXudPIG70k https://t.co/RIjIoRCuw5 pic.twitter.com/hVb60tpFTC
"This is an exceedingly common bicycle lock," commented one X user. "It’s a type Columbia public safety has promoted to its students. How did this claim get all the way onto tv?"
"I have that bicycle chain. For my bike. Normal in NYC," responded someone else.
"That’s a bike lock," quipped a Democratic New York state assembly member representing parts of Brooklyn.
Noted someone else: "This appears to be the recommended chain bike lock from Wirecutter?"
This appears to be the recommended chain bike lock from Wirecutter? https://t.co/jZuOJ7d9R4 pic.twitter.com/u00tsSbIkU
— tyson brody (@tysonbrody) May 1, 2024
Another person said Shepard's comments about the chain and lock show that the NYPD is "trying to further push the 'outside agitator' narrative at Columbia."
"This is a Kryptonite bike chain, similar to what you can see here (pointed out in a yet unpublished community note)," concluded Bellingcat founder Eliot Higgins. "Do only vaguely defined 'professionals' use bike chains?"
But when facing pushback from a reporter showing a similar—or possibly same—bike chain available for sale, Shepard doubled down by saying it is different.
Here is @katie_honan confronting @NYPDDCPI with evidence that the chain he wielded to imply that “outside agitators” barricaded Hamilton Hall is a common bike lock that @Columbia itself sold to their students pic.twitter.com/j7lU9Nm1GO
— Christopher Robbins (@ChristRobbins) May 1, 2024
"Look at this, this is an industrial chain," he countered.
The internet is chaotic—but we’ll break it down for you in one daily email. Sign up for the Daily Dot’s web_crawlr newsletter here to get the best (and worst) of the internet straight into your inbox.






