Who won the first Democratic debate of the 2016 election cycle?
Either Bernie Sanders or Hillary Clinton, depending on which first-reaction metric you believe.
Sanders, the straight-talk independent senator from Vermont, walked away from the CNN stage with the win, a variety of Web-based metrics show. The pundits, on the other hand, have stacked the win firmly in Clinton’s corner, putting the narrative of Sanders’ victory in question.
On Google, Sanders was the most searched-for candidate on the debate stage, followed by Clinton, former Virginia Sen. Jim Webb, former Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley, and Lincoln Chafee, the former Rhode Island senator and governor.
… and this is how the #DemDebate candidate rankings stand at the end of the debatehttps://t.co/28tOS8mPXp pic.twitter.com/yiJhiZSZ20
— GoogleTrends (@GoogleTrends) October 14, 2015
Sanders also dominated a poll from the right-leaning Drudge Report, which gave Sanders a commanding 37-point lead over Webb, at the time of publication.
And on Facebook, “Bernie Sanders” trended one spot higher than “Hillary Clinton” in the hour after the debate, which itself took the top-trending spot. The hashtag #DamnEmails, a reference to Sanders’ condemnation of Republicans’ focus on Clinton’s private email use during her time as secretary of state, came in a close fourth.
Sanders also reigned supreme on Twitter, clocking in more mentions than any other candidate on the stage.
Most mentioned candidates on Twitter, w/ share of #DemDebate conversation:
— Government (@Gov) October 14, 2015
Sanders – 41%
Clinton – 39%
Webb – 9%
O’Malley – 6%
Chafee – 5%
#DemDebate graphic comparing Twitter conversation about @HillaryClinton and @BernieSanders: http://t.co/rM6viQZ3jH pic.twitter.com/fuvI0aHwF7
— Government (@Gov) October 14, 2015
Meanwhile, Donald Trump, the businessman and GOP frontrunner, still managed to make his mark during the Democratic debate—coming in third in overall Twitter mentions.
Top candidates (either party) mentioned on Twitter during #DemDebate so far:
— Government (@Gov) October 14, 2015
1. Clinton
2. Sanders
3. Trump
Despite Sanders’ clear victory online, many of those tasked with pontificating on the candidates’ debate performances counted Tuesday night as a win for Clinton. The Guardian, New York Magazine, and Bloomberg all crowned Clinton the winner.
Considering that we are more than a year away from Election Day, however, it remains to be seen how much these quick-poll reactions will matter in the long run.
Correction: Sanders’ lead in the Drudge Report poll was 37 points.
Updated 8:23am CT, Oct. 14: Added new Twitter metrics and views from political pundits.
Illustration by Max Fleishman
